Perfumes Similar to Rosie by Rosie Jane: Reddit-Tested & Expert Verified
Why People Love Rosie by Rosie Jane (and Why It’s Hard to Replace)
Minimalist, clean, and intimate Rosie by Rosie Jane has earned cult status as a soft “your-skin-but-better” scent. Featuring a blend of rose, vanilla, and white musk, it wraps the skin in subtle freshness that smells natural, warm, and gently floral.
But with limited availability (especially in the UK), fans are looking for the next best thing.
That’s where we come in: we scoured Reddit threads, fragrance forums, and review platforms to find the closest matches from budget-friendly dupes to luxurious upgrades.
Reddit Recommends: Perfumes That Smell Like Rosie by Rosie Jane
We analyzed a live Reddit thread where perfume lovers compared their favorite Rosie alternatives. Then we validated the suggestions using verified pricing, real-world reviews, and fragrance breakdowns.
Here are the top picks :
1. Mancera Roses Vanille
“Roses Vanille by Mancera has similar notes but it is stronger.” – u/ProfBeautySally
Notes: Lemon, Rose, Vanilla, White Musk, Sugar
Why It’s Similar: Same rose + vanilla heart, but with a richer, bolder twist.
Price: $125.00 (60ml)
Longevity: 8–10+ hours
Reviews: ★★★★☆ 4.6/5 (Fragrantica)
- Official Product : Mancera Roses Vanille
🟢 Great for fans who want more projection and winter wearability.
2. Montale Roses Musk
“There is Roses Musk by Montale.” – u/ProfBeautySally
Notes: Rose, Jasmine, Musk
Why It’s Similar: Emphasizes Rosie’s rosy-musk base, but stronger and more metallic.
Price: $180.00 (100ml)
Longevity: 10+ hours
Reviews: ★★★★☆ 4.3/5
- Official Product : Montale Roses Musk
🟢 Think Rosie with an edge powerful but elegant.
3. Lake & Skye 11 11
“The first thing I thought of was 11 11—it smells so similar to Rosie.” – u/Rae818
“Came here to say this!” – u/Jacksummer100
Notes: White Musk, Amber, Clean Skin Accord
Why It’s Similar: Both evoke a clean skin scent, soft and airy with musk dominance.
Price: $98 (50ml)
Longevity: 4–6 hours
Reviews: ★★★★☆ 4.6/5 (Sephora)
- Official Product : Lake & Skye 11 11
🟢 Perfect for “clean girl” aesthetic lovers who want subtle elegance.
4. Fleur Musc for Her – Narciso Rodriguez
“No vanilla, but a gorgeous rose musk. Lasts all day!” – u/glitterllama
Notes: Rose, Musk, Pink Pepper, Amber, Patchouli
Why It’s Similar: Leans more sophisticated and spicy, but still rose-musk centered.
Price: $104 (50ml)
Longevity: 6–8 hours
Reviews: ★★★★☆ 4.5/5
- Official Product : Fleur Musk For Her – Narciso Rodriguez
🟢 Ideal for someone who wants the “grown-up” version of Rosie.
Comparison Chart
| Perfume | Why It’s Similar | Price | Longevity | Rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Roses Vanille | Rose + vanilla dupe, but stronger | $125.00 | 8–10 hrs | 4.6★ |
| Roses Musk | Rosy musk focus, metallic edge | $180.00 | 10+ hrs | 4.3★ |
| Lake & Skye 11 11 | Clean, soft musk skin scent | $98 | 4–6 hrs | 4.6★ |
| Fleur Musc (Narciso) | Rosy musk with spice and depth | $104 | 6–8 hrs | 4.5★ |
If you miss the soft, rosy-musk whisper of Rosie by Rosie Jane, any of these dupes can help recreate the vibe—some louder, some cleaner, some deeper.
✅ Want more vanilla sweetness? Try Mancera Roses Vanille.
✅ Prefer the clean skin scent vibe? Go with Lake & Skye 11 11.
✅ Like sophistication and power? Fleur Musc is your match.
Whichever you pick, make sure to test it on skin it’s the only way to know if it truly becomes “you.”
FAQ About rosie by rosie jane
What notes are in Rosie by Rosie Jane?
Rosie includes notes of rose, vanilla, and white musk, designed to evoke a fresh, clean-skin scent.
Is there a dupe for Rosie by Rosie Jane?
Yes! Reddit users recommend Lake & Skye 11 11, Mancera Roses Vanille, and Montale Roses Musk as close alternatives.
Which Rosie dupe lasts the longest?
Montale Roses Musk and Mancera Roses Vanille both offer over 8+ hours of wear time.
Where can I find Rosie by Rosie Jane in the UK?
Availability is limited. Look for UK-based stockists on Cult Beauty, Space NK, or use global shipping services.
